The
Mediterranean Garden Society


Ask the Expert, Questions & Answers

Our service "Ask the Expert, Questions & Answers" was set up as a result of the many questions we received from members on a range of subjects, since to answer them properly required specialised knowledge.

The Scientific Committee has identified a number of experts within the MGS who are happy to help with your enquiries. Their subjects range from bulbs, olives, pests, diseases and weed control, to soil science, water plants, flower and plant identification, agronomy, medicinal plants and plant physiology. Please note that it is difficult to identify plants accurately from photographs and thus fresh flower samples are preferred.

It is very simple: just send your question by e-mail, marked "expert", and we'll pass it on to the appropriate expert.

This service is only available to signed-up members of the MGS.

A selection of interesting questions and answers will be published as "Q & A"  on this page.


Question - This enquiry was sent to us by a member living in Cyprus. The plant in question is a 2-3m high shrub, growing on a track between Goudi and Polis, in western Cyprus, altitude <50m. As the photos show, it is well-clothed in mid-green entire leaves and red berries. The latter are sub-spherical, and with a distinctive sort of husk (green). The member adds: "I hope you can name this for me!"
Read the answer.

Question - "This year we noticed a very beautiful moth in our garden in the Languedoc Roussillon part of France and took some pictures of it. I wonder if you know this moth? I understand that it comes originally from South America and that it is harmful to palm trees."
Read the answer.

Question - "A few days ago we spotted the plant in the attached photograph flowering in the wild at Ostia Antica, near Rome. We have no idea what it is, can you help? Hmm, I would have said perhaps Trachymene caerulea except that I don't think the leaves look right. It was growing at sea level in the excavations: in ancient Roman times this was a sea port and is now about one kilometre inland because the Tiber estuary/delta has gradually silted up. I did not see any signs of underground water but perhaps was not observant enough.

I found the plant growing in the ruins of a Roman building, as it were in a "room", of course open to the light. It was in a very sunny position, except that the shadow of the walls may fall upon it for a few hours; it was not close to the walls (but rooms in ancient Roman houses were not very large) and was growing in hard, dry, what seemed slightly sandy earth - probably calcareous since the water here is very hard indeed. I found it on 4 September, just before the first autumn rains. The plant was still making buds, and did not yet have any seed at all as it was just beginning to flower.

Almost nothing else was growing there, it was so parched and sun-baked. So imagine the delight of suddenly coming upon sprays of blueish-purple!"
Read the answer.

Question - "Can anyone identify the caterpillars that for the first time have been ravaging our santolinas this year? (Our garden is in a rather arid part of Provence.) There are small apparently black ones and larger slightly bristly ones of a dull brown with greenish-yellow markings on their backs and crescent shapes of the same colour outlined in black on their sides. I suspect that both are the same species, the ‘black’ ones being at an earlier stage of development, for although they appear uniformly dark to the naked eye, a magnified digital photograph reveals faint yellowish markings on their backs corresponding to the marks on the larger caterpillars.

They appeared in late April and early May following heavier than usual winter and spring rains and they stripped 4-year-old santolinas of all their leaves (S. chamaecyparissus and S. neapolitana ‘Edward Bowles’). We have also found them on a neighbouring lavender plant and on wild rosemary plants. Clearly they have a taste for the aromatic.

We have never seen caterpillars on any of these plants before. We’d love to know of what butterfly or moth they are the larvae."
Read the answer.

Question - "It`s a cry for assistance! Our mulberries, which are very important in our garden have begun to die very quickly this week. There are yellow marks on the leaves on the branches and on the fallen leaves. No insects or caterpillars. Perhaps it`s a virus or the spring rains. What should I do? Please could you inform of any internet sites or experts which could help. I have looked at the internet but the information is a little confusing."
Read the answer.

Question - "Attached is a photo of flower taken in the Sibillini mountains yesterday,  I have searched through my library of wild flowers and indeed the internet to no avail. Is there anyone among the experts who could please identify it for me? "
Read the answer.

Question - "I have long been contemplating some sort of water feature/watery element in my garden. I would like to attract wildlife, to enjoy the sight of an area of water and − why not? − when the weather permits, bathe in my "pool". I have read about "natural swimming pools" in a number of books and garden magazines but most seem to be in northern climes. One local garden designer and nurseryman told me categorically that the natural pool could not be achieved here because of our high summer temperatures. Could you advise, please?"
Read the answer.

Question - "I have recently seen articles which report that certain vermiculites could contain asbestos. Could you comment on the health and safety aspects of using vermiculite?"
Read the answer.

Question - " Why do some plants like Hibiscus mutabilis or Rosa chinensis have flowers that turn a different colour as they open, mature and die?"
Read the answer.

Question - "Can you identify this extraordinary plant (below) I found growing in gravel close to Anduze, in Languedoc, France? The gravel was brought in about 10  years ago and overlies an alluvial soil deposit."
Read the answer.

Question - "I want to ask someone about green manures that might help in citrus cultivation. I live in drought-devastated Cyprus and cannot give the many trees I have as much water as they need. (I know they are not good plants for dry gardening, but my house came with lots of them). So I thought I might at least help them with some organic companion plants. I have constraints of what is appropriate and what is available."
Read the answer.

Question - "Suggestions are urgently needed as to how to combat the voracious bush cricket (Peocilimon ornatus?) that visits us in large numbers in the spring in our small garden in southern Greece. The cricket attacks orange and pomegranate trees, eating leaves, buds and young fruit with its very powerful jaws. A year ago the crickets destroyed a very large cistus. The cricket is easily recognisable with its central black stripe and two parallel yellow stripes along its back. On its sides it has very smart markings of green/black chevrons. At the moment, the only mode of defence is to catch and squash these crickets.  This is not difficult but time-consuming and not very effective. Although no chemical addict, I would reckon that an early spray before fruit has set would be safe toxic-wise − but what spray?"
Read the answer.

Question - "Cestrum nocturnum gives off its scent at night in pronounced waves or pulses. How does the plant do this physiologically? And what are the advantages of a pulsed scent rather than a steady scent?"
Read the answer.


Answer (November 2008) - " All flowers have evolved mechanisms to achieve successful pollination. C. nocturnum produces an intensively fragrant "volatile" scent during the night to attract its pollinator, a moth of the noctuid family (Agrotis spp), see page 40 of TMG number 35. The moth relies on the fragrance to guide it to the flower: it has its own GPS system. Moths may be attracted from a distance of over six metres.

The moth has a long proboscis and the ability to hover while drinking the nectar at the base of the flower. The proboscis is guided by a slit in the anther, leaving behind sticky pollen which is then transferred to the next moth, and so on. Up to nine species of hovering moth have been identified as pollinators.

Flower fragrances probably originated to deter herbivores; however, visiting insects selectively chose those flowers which provided food. Another evolutionary scenario could be that moths would be more likely to find a mate also visiting the same flower. The circadian cycle also attracts species that are frequent during the night, for example the noctuid moth.

Scents are usually produced from the metabolism of the cell membrane, with the corolla, pollen or nectar often being involved. The advantage of a pulsed scent compared to a steady scent is not clear. It may be that it reduces olfactory fatigue in the pollinating insect. A "flashing" scent may be more noticeable than a steady scent. Pulsed scents may travel longer distances, the weaker/stronger smell may be more efficient in attracting moths, or it could be a trigger controlled by exterior factors such as temperature. The trait to respond to a scent is rapidly learnt since there is an immediate reward. The pulsing may also be related to the concentration of the chemicals involved. Thus a number of reactions may be involved in the production of the scent and the scent release is stopped until the necessary precursor chemicals are generated.  At some critical concentration the scent is then released again.

Odours are especially prominent in "primitive" plants. There are four categories of odour described as heavy, aromatic, lemon and foxy. The fragrance of C. nocturnum has been described as a mix of musk and heliotrope.

Some other night-flowering plants include Brugmansia candida, Ipomoea alba, Oenothera spp and Petunia spp."


(March 2010) - "Following on from the response already given, I have been looking through the research that has been carried out on Cestrum nocturnum. There is certainly mention of the release of the scent, but I have not found specific research on fragrance being released in pulses. 

The first interesting point is that the scent release is an endogenously (internally) controlled circadian rhythm, i.e. it is found in a cyclic (24h circadian) manner, both in constant darkness and constant light at constant temperature. As scent is usually released in the evening, but the corolla behaves endogenously, there must be an additional ' zeitgeber' (from the German for time-giver, synchronizer) which synchronizes the flower's endogenous (internal) time-keeping system (clock) to the earth's 24-hour light/dark cycle. This might be in another part of the plant, for example the leaves, as the strongest 'zeitgeber' in plants is light although it can also be temperature. Although in nature in constant conditions this rhythm is a period of roughly 24 hours, it is affected by temperature, with the cycle lengthened in colder temperatures and reduced at higher temperatures (Overland, 1960). As mentioned in the previous answer, there may be a number of reactions which would lead to the release of scent, therefore if one or more of these reactions were temperature-dependent the cycle would be extended. 

Research has also been carried out to examine the constituent components of the scent (Al-Reza et al., 2009). The extract was found to contain alkaloids, flavonol glycosides, steroidal saponins, fatty acids, essential oils phenols, and others (Bouchbaver et al., 1995). The chemical components of the scent are volatile compounds which facilitate their release into the atmosphere. As mentioned in the previous answer, scents are usually produced by metabolism of compounds within the cells and the corolla is often involved. The corolla was shown to control this mechanism as the cycle exists independently in excised corolla tips (Overland, 1960).

In snapdragon flowers, the same endogenous activity was shown by examining the release of methyl benzoate, one of the most abundant scent compounds of bee-pollinated snapdragon flowers (Kolosova et al., 2001). This research showed that the total amount of benzoic acid available in the cells was a determining factor in the regulation of the rhythmic emission of scent. This could be evidence that scent is only released once a sufficient supply of precursor chemicals is built up, leading to a pulsed scent. 

A simpler explanation for the observed release of scent could be atmospheric conditions, i.e. temperature fluctuation, humidity or simply very gentle breezes that give the impression of a pulsed release of scent, or additional release of the volatile compounds from the cell surfaces. 

I have discussed this with an evolutionary biologist, Dr Elisabet Sahtouris, and she offered an additional theory that it could also be an economic use of the volatile compounds over a longer period."


Answer (November 2008) - "The best chemicals to use are the synthetic pyrethroids − not pyrethrum. They are extremely active at very low dosages and very effective on most insects but they are broad-spectrum, killing both the good and the bad. There are several products to choose from. The common names of some of the active ingredients are: permethrin, deltamethrin and cypermethrin.

You should be able to find these in a garden store or at your local agricultural co-operative. They are sold under several trademarks. The key is to ask or look for the common name on the label.

These products are effective as contact sprays (direct your spray at the adult) or by ingestion,  assuming they eat a lethal dose on the plant they will die. These products are quite persistent, especially permethrin.

There are baits available, for example "Advion" from Dupont. You might ask if it is available locally. I have never made a cricket bait but it would be worth a go. It is directed at the pests and is therefore more specific. Try mixing oatmeal, rice, or cornflakes, whatever you think may be attractive to the adult, with a solution of the insecticide you use, i.e. deltamethrin. Try 1 part in 1000 parts and mix in with the bait. Wear gloves."


Answer (December 2008) - "Our first expert was dubious of the value of cover crops, saying that citrus trees are natives of South East Asia where rain is usually plentiful and that irrigation is indispensable. Any benefits accruing from companion plants may be outweighed by the competition for water with the citrus trees.

Several companion plants were suggested including any local vetch or medic, clover (Trifolium spp.) or even Phaseolus beans. Broad beans (Vicia faba) and Sinapis arvensis had been successfully tried, mainly because seed was available. These plants should be heavily seeded with autumn rains and scratched into the soil surface. The additional nitrogen from the legumes was considered to be beneficial. The companion crop should die down with the onset of summer heat and form a mulch. However, if this does not happen the companion plant can be "burnt-off" with glyphosate. This will eliminate competition for any available water.

The decorative perennial Aptenia was considered an excellent cover crop; however, whether it would do in this situation is open to debate.

One expert recommended that on no account should the mulch or cover crop be turned into the soil. Cultivation led to loss of organic matter through photodecomposition, destroyed soil structure leading to run-off and soil erosion, as well as to the loss of earthworms and other microorganisms.

Yet another expert advised "any kind of mulch" to improve water retention. Citrus trees are heavy feeders and it would be good to have the mulch well rotted so that the decomposition process does not rob nitrogen from the soil. The mulch is recommended to be at least 12" (30 cm) from the trunk of the tree. Cotton waste, waste grapes and stalks from local wineries, shredded and composted vegetable waste from municipal recycling plants could all be used. Any sort of "hard" mulch is recommended, including gravel and local stones.

Finally Jennifer Gay's gardening column in the Athens News was recommended for local practical experience:
"Concerning your recent article on cover crops, we are considering implementing this on some unfinished land. The earth there is like rock, so we are considering bell beans or mustard radishes, with strong taproots to try, and I assume these come in seed form, but can you recommend anywhere in Athens to get these seeds?
Greek agronomists tell me that farmers here traditionally used the method, often doubling green manure up as a fodder crop, eaten off by animals. As winter ended, it was ploughed into the ground. It is quite possible that, with the advent of inorganic fertilisers, people have forgotten the importance of turning in crops at the end of the season. It should be possible to buy cover crop seed in most garden stores. Two such crops commonly still in use are bell bean (Vicia faba), or alfalfa/lucerne (Medicago sativa). I don't know the Greek for the oilseed radish I mentioned, but the Latin name is often shown on the packet and is Raphanus sativus var oleiferus. It is a variant of the Greek native Raphanus sativus."


Answer (December 2008) - "It is impossible to identify accurately plants a) from a photograph and b) without floral parts. Identification from vegetation is at best, a best guess.

However there is a great possibility that this plant is Solanum sisymbrifolium, a member of the Solanaceae, naturalised from tropical America.

This plant is definitely not Solanum elaeagnifolium, silver-leaved nightshade, which is a "dreadful spreading invasive" in the Mediterranean."


Answer (January 2009) - "Flower colour depends on the presence of pigments in the flower (or leaves, stems and fruit), upon the pH (the acidity or alkalinity), the genetic make-up and other conditions of the sap in the plant cell. Several pigments are concerned. The most common are the yellow and orange colours contained within the cell plastid (a cellule containing the chloroplasts), the red, purple, blue and orange anthocyanins and the yellow to ivory anthoxanthins. Flowers contain some pigments but not others.

Background effects are shown when two different-coloured pigments are present. 

Colour variation and change may be brought about by dilution or intensification of the pigment present within the cell and all show a marked sensitivity to the pH of the cell sap.  For example, under acid conditions red colours are more pronounced but under alkaline conditions blues/violets are stronger. This leads to different colours in the same flower. Pigments are also water-soluble, giving rise to "local" variation.

The colour change in Lathyrus hirsutus, hairy vetch, is well studied. The mature standard petal is pale blueish red and fades through blue to greenish blue; the wing petals are pale blue and fade to greenish blue. The pH of the sap in the wings is higher than that in the standard petal and this may account for the bluer appearance in the wing petal.

Flower pigments play an important role in the attraction of pollinators.

Another theory highlights the importance of pollination and colour change. In a study with yellow Lantana flowers the presence of one grain of pollen triggered the synthesis of anthocyanins which masked the existing carotenoid colours. Since thrips are attracted only to yellow flowers, the change in colour may be attributed to conserving the energy of the pollinator insect."


Answer (March 2009) - "Vermiculite is a naturally occurring mineral generally derived from mica. On heating, mica granules expand greatly to give a lightweight highly water-absorbent material that is used in horticulture and in numerous industrial applications including in plaster, mortar, in concrete and as insulation in walls, floors and ceilings. It has been demonstrated to be safe to use, and no serious health risks have been found to result from exposure to vermiculite.

During the 1960s one particular mine in the USA was found to be producing vermiculite contaminated with asbestiform material. The contamination was due to the fact that the vermiculite sat directly on top of an asbestos deposit.

All naturally occurring materials have characteristics which reflect the particular deposit where the stuff is being mined, thus asbestos contamination may exist for a wide range of materials including sand, clay and gypsum.

There are numerous sources of commercial vermiculite ores in the world which are currently in use by the major producers and which do not pose a risk to the user. In fact it is estimated that over 500,000 tonnes of vermiculite are safely mined and sold around the world per annum.

It is important, however, to note that the possibility of fibrous asbestos contamination exists for a wide range of naturally occurring materials and it is thus inappropriate to state that any such material is asbestos-free.

The above represents a summary of the information available on vermiculite. In our opinion members of the MGS should be aware that a risk, however small, may exist with all naturally occurring products; it is up to each member to make his own assessment of risk based on his exposure to them."


Answer (March 2009) - "Our experience is that it is perfectly possible to have a swimming pond in quite an extreme climate: we are zone 10 in gardening terms, which means that we rarely get frost and have highs of 40°C occasionally in the summer months but more regularly up to 30°C air temperature. The aim of the pool constructors is to match the plant community used to clean the pond water to the make-up of the water itself, thus copying nature and providing an experience similar to that of bathing in a river or lake. Size and shape is not important and you can have a dizzying variety of shapes, with large rocks, cascades, bridges etc. Have a look at the gallery section on the web site below for some ideas.

We have had our pond since June 2005 and it is just great, every year bringing more maturity in to the plantings and the surroundings. We have tried to keep these in tune with the landscape as much as possible, using large drought tolerant grasses and native plants, gravel, large flat stones and some small paved areas for contrast. We have many visitors and even those who are a bit sceptical about swimming in a pond have always jumped in and thoroughly enjoyed being eyeball to eyeball with little frogs on the lily pad leaves, seeing the spectacular red and blue dragonflies at close quarters and watching the swallows dunking themselves in the pond. It is good not to have to worry about chlorine, salt or any other water treatments, we can flop in and out of the pond as many times a day as we like and our skin, sinuses (and bathing suits) are soft and sweet-smelling.

Rosie Peddle wrote an article in the MGS journal, TMG 44, April 2006, entitled "A pond for swimming in".

There is a lovely blog by another MGS member in Umbria. (Click on the pond link in the list of topics.)

The International Federation of Natural Bathing also has a gallery of photos of ponds."


Answer (June 2009) - "The plant has been identified as Cynoglossum magellense, a Boraginaceae and an Italian endemic.

The photo was taken by an MGS member in the National Park of Mount Sibillini in Italy. The park was established in 1993 and covers some 70,000 hectares and reaches an altitude of 2,500m."


Answer (July 2009) - "It is very difficult to give a precise answer from a written description however there are two diseases recorded on “mulberry”. Gibberella moricola or canker and die-back of mulberry has been recorded in France and Italy. The most conspicuous features are large cankers on the stems beyond which the foliage turns yellow and wilts leading to die back. This genus has been reported to cause rapid wilting of the leaves followed by chlorosis and necrosis. A cross-section of the infected leaf/branch should show vascular discoloration.

Another authority confirmed that G. baccata is the commonest cause of shoot and twig dieback of Morus.

There is little published data however one reference did recommend that hygiene would help (which does not help very much) or the use of a modern systemic fungicide such as benomyl or thiabendazole.

The other recorded disease is Rosellinia aquila which has been reported to invade the roots of mulberry trees. When a large part of the roots are infected there is a progressive yellowing of the leaves and die-back!

I think I would be tempted to cut out the disease branches well below the infected area. Burn the cuttings and collect and leaves and burn. A drench of one of the systemics listed above may help but I realise this may be difficult on mature mulberry trees."


Answer (August 2009) - "The plants on which caterpillars feed are very indicative of their species. A search for santolina indicates (as far as I can discover – but my information could be very far from complete) two species of moth whose larvae feed on this plant: Eupithecia santolinata, a rare species found in Provence, and Cucullia santolinae, which seems to be more common around the Mediterranean. I tend to plump for this species.

The members raising the question also agree that their caterpillar resembles the latter species."


Answer (September 2009) - "This is Trachelium caeruleum, a not uncommon plant in the Mediterranean. It often likes damp walls in shade, though."


Answer (December 2009) - "This is a photograph of Paysandisia archon, a moth belonging to the Castniidae family with a palm-boring caterpillar. It is a native pest of Argentina and Uruguay and was first recorded in France in 1999, in Spain in 2001 and in Mallorca in 2003. It is now recorded throughout the Mediterranean Basin including in France, Italy, Spain and the Balearic islands. Its larvae attack many palms, but prefer - in order - Chamaerops humilis, Phoenix canariensis, Trachycarpus fortunei and Washingtonia spp.

At home the Paysandisia archon larva infests palm trees but it is kept in check by natural predators and parasites. It appears to have been brought to Europe accidentally on imported palms which are now being planted by many municipalities throughout the Mediterranean Basin to replace the existing plane trees, many of which are old and diseased.

The beautiful moth is large, some 90-110mm across, with dark green front wings with brown streaking, and bright red back wings with bold black and white markings. The adults fly during the day from May to September. Eggs are laid in the palm crowns where the grubs hatch. The caterpillar first eats tender leaves at the heart and then bores into the trunk during a period of one to two years.The first sign of attack is a very regular series of holes in the emerging fronds. Later, there will be piles of sawdust mixed with excrement at the base of the fronds and finally, after pruning, holes and even cocoons will be seen in the base. The grub will over-winter and will stay in the larval stage for up to 18 months. Without control the plant will eventually wilt and die.

Detection and control are difficult as larvae cannot be seen or reached easily within the crown. Periodic inspections will reveal any damage in the emerging young fronds. Chamaerops humilis is especially vulnerable as its heart is so small. Since this moth is not a pest in its native country no control method has yet been developed. It is believed that the moth could spread to a much larger region in the future if measures are not taken; however, natural predators may also be introduced with the imported palms.

A good soaking of the heart with an insecticide containing chlorpyriphos and dimethoate should be effective; this is not a general recommendation, however, and appropriate authorities should be contacted before any attempt is made to spray these pests.

In Nîmes, specimen palms are covered with large plastic netting to prevent egg-laying but this does take away some of the beauty of the palm tree.

Rhynchophorus ferrugineus is another pest of imported palm trees. This is a member of the coleoptera originating in Asia and Malaysia which arrived in Spain in 1995 and was first detected in Mallorca in 2006. It attacks a great variety of palms, with a preference for Phoenix canariensis, Phoenix dactylifera, and Washingtonia spp.

The adult is 2-5cm long and 1 cm wide, coloured red, with black spots on the body, corrugated wing sheaths, and a long beak.

The first parts of the palm to be attacked are the most tender leaves at the heart and then the trunk. Usually the first sign of damage is the collapse of the central fronds, by which time the palm is moribund.

In view of the dangers posed by this pest and the absence to date of effective treatments, experiments are being carried out in many different areas of the Mediterranean, ranging from spraying regularly through the summer, through avoiding pruning except in the winter, to zapping the crown of an infected palm with a batch of microwave "ovens" mounted on extended forklifts.

Please see page 15 of TMG 56 for additional information"


Answer (January 2010) - "I think the plant is a species of Lycium and some of our specimens, L. barbarum (Duke of Argyll's tea-tree), match the photos. L. barbarum is not recorded for Greece in the Flora Europaea, but it does say that this Chinese plant has been widely planted as hedging in the Mediterranean. It has bright red fruits that look like little tomatoes, though with this family they could be poisonous!

However, another expert considers the plant to be Lycium schweinfurthii, which is apparently common in Cyprus and can have red or dark spherical berries. Lycium is a member of the Solanaceae family. L. chinense (Chinese boxthorn) is widely distributed in eastern China and L. barbarum is mainly localised in China. Fresh leaves and ripe berries are common in Chinese cooking.

The seeds of L. barbarum are commercially available from a French seeds company, Baumaux, and are described under the name "Goji" in its 2010 spring seed catalogue, page 581. Baumaux claims that this plant contains 400 times more vitamin C than the orange, and 13% more protein than wheat."




 

 

www.MediterraneanGardenSociety.org
All content (c) copyrighted by source or author, not to be reproduced without authorization.


see also gardening in mediterranean climates worldwide

 

This website is maintained by Truetype Web Solutions